Refine Search
Sort by
$271,000
2 Beds 2 Baths
Welcome to this Stunning Cape Cod Home which has been totally renovated in the past five years. This excellent location is close to the Riverside Park & Zoo, Independence Sports Complex and Walking Trails. The current owners poured their hearts into this home keeping as much of it's history as possible. The hardwood floors, beautiful beamed ceiling, trim and moulding are mostly original to the home. While keeping the footprint of the home, the kitchen and butler's pantry boast soft close cabinetry and quartz countertops. The gas kitchen range is also a convection oven with a custom hood. All top of the line appliances including the stacked washer&dryer will remain. The large screen TV perfect over the decorative firplace will also remain. The large living, family and dining rooms are perfect for family gatherings and would be beautiful decorated for Christmas. The arched front door and stone steps as well as the side courtyard area are unique features. Both bathrooms are "spa like" with quartz extra tall countertops, tile floors and walk in showers. The primary bathroom has a double vanity. There is potential to add a room in the attic area and plans are available for a garage. Too many extras to mention...Don't miss this opportunity to own this beautiful home!

1222 N 2nd Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Debra Johnson of Coldwell Banker Pasternak Johnson.

$274,900
3 Beds 1.5 Baths
Welcome to this amazing Historic Prairie Style Home! It blends timeless character with a great location featuring a walkable lifestyle to downtown, the Indy Sports Complex and the Riverside Park and Zoo. The home has 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. There are 2 sunporches (one on the main and one on the 2nd level) that could be used as additional bedrooms. The updated kitchen has a butler's pantry and the enclosed back porch has been converted into a laundry area. The character of the home is evident in the wood beams, trim, flooring and the 3 gas fireplaces. There is a partial unfinished basement and a detached 2 car garage. The spacious front porch is the perfect place to sit and enjoy your morning cup of coffee. The details of the history of this home in Ken Brown's (local historian) Historic Home Book dated 1993 are available to potential buyers. Contact us for a tour!

400 E Locust Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Debra Johnson of Coldwell Banker Pasternak Johnson.

$239,900
3 Beds 2.5 Baths
Step into the kind of HOME that allows your family to spread out, come together and use the space for your needs. Great location, large privacy fenced yard with fun entertainment spaces and great shade. The spacious primary bedroom and bath are on the main level while the 2 other nice size bedrooms are upstairs and share a bathroom. The upstairs bedrooms each have 2 closets and the vaulted ceilings add space and character. The main level has 2 living spaces, kitchen, dining area, laundry area, 1/2 bath plus the primary bedroom/bathroom. There is a woodburning fireplace with an insert in the living room perfect for those extra cold nights. All of the windows were replaced by Windows USA in 2021, they are Low-E and have a Lifetime Warranty. There are 2 heat and air units and they have been replaced since the owner has purchased the property. Call to see this lovely home today!

2531 N 8th Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Debra Johnson of Coldwell Banker Pasternak Johnson.

$735,000
5 Beds 4.5 Baths
You can stop scrolling—this is the one that ends the search. Set on 7.06 acres of quiet, private ground, this custom-built brick home delivers over 5,300 sq ft of space, presence, and quality you feel the second you walk in. With 5 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, and a full finished walk-out basement, it’s built to live in—but designed to impress. The moment you step through the front door, your eyes are pulled straight to the back wall of windows. Nothing but trees, wide-open nature, and a peaceful glimpse of Montgomery County State Lake. It’s the kind of view people hope for—and almost never find. This home wasn’t thrown together—you’ll notice that immediately. From the craftsmanship to the materials, every detail was intentional. An intercom system, built-in ceiling speakers, dimmable lighting throughout, and a layout that flows effortlessly between comfort and style. The main level offers everyday living that feels anything but ordinary, while the walk-out basement—with a full second kitchen—opens the door for entertaining, hosting, or multi-generational living. Step outside and it only gets better. Exotic tigerwood decking leads you down to a covered patio, creating the perfect space to take in the view and unwind. The backyard is fenced for pets, and the property is equipped with a whole-house Generac generator with its own propane tank, giving you peace of mind year-round. With two HVAC systems, a safe room, and a Clearstream aerobic septic system, this home checks boxes most don’t even think to ask about. And if you’re looking for a true turnkey experience—there’s an option to purchase the home fully furnished with all decor included. This isn’t just a home—it’s the one people wait for.

3620 CR 3920 Road, Independence

Listing courtesy of Jackie Schierlman of EXP Realty LLC.

$119,900
5 Beds 3 Baths
Step into timeless charm with this character-filled bungalow that’s just waiting to be brought back to life! Featuring classic stucco and brick veneer, this home makes a statement from the start with its inviting covered front porch—perfect for morning coffee or winding down in the evenings. Inside, you’ll find beautiful original hardwood floors and the kind of craftsmanship and character you simply can’t recreate. The layout offers incredible space and flexibility with 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms on the main level, plus 3 additional bedrooms and a bathroom upstairs—ideal for a growing household or anyone needing extra room. The large kitchen provides plenty of space to reimagine and make your own, while the abundance of windows fills the home with natural light throughout. Situated on a large corner lot, there’s room to spread out both inside and out. The full unfinished basement offers excellent storage (or future potential), and while the old garage entrance is no longer functional, there is still convenient parking available. This is the kind of home that, with a little vision and some updates, could truly shine again and be restored to its original beauty. If you love character, space, and the opportunity to create something special—this one is calling your name!

419 S 4th Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Amber Gregory of Keller Williams Realty Select.

The data relating to real estate displayed on this website comes in part from the Heartland Multiple Listing Service database compilation. The properties displayed on this website may not be all of the properties in the Heartland MLS database compilation, or all of the properties listed with other brokers participating in the Heartland MLS IDX program. Detailed information about the properties displayed on this website includes the name of the listing company.

The information displayed on this page is confidential, proprietary, and copyrighted information of Heartland Multiple Listing Service, Inc. (“Heartland MLS”). Copyright 2026, Heartland Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Heartland MLS and the company represented by this website do not make any warranty or representation concerning the timeliness or accuracy of the information displayed herein. In consideration for the receipt of the information on this page, the recipient agrees to use the information solely for the private noncommercial purpose of identifying a property in which the recipient has a good faith interest in acquiring. Data last updated . Terms of Use