Refine Search
Sort by
400 E Locust Street, Independence
$268,500
3 Beds ⋅ 1.5 Baths
Welcome to this amazing Historic Prairie Style Home! It blends timeless character with a great location featuring a walkable lifestyle to downtown, the Indy Sports Complex and the Riverside Park and Zoo. The home has 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. There are 2 sunporches (one on the main and one on the 2nd level) that could be used as additional bedrooms. The updated kitchen has a butler's pantry and the enclosed back porch has been converted into a laundry area. The character of the home is evident in the wood beams, trim, flooring and the 3 gas fireplaces. There is a partial unfinished basement and a detached 2 car garage. The spacious front porch is the perfect place to sit and enjoy your morning cup of coffee. The details of the history of this home in Ken Brown's (local historian) Historic Home Book dated 1993 are available to potential buyers. This Seller is offering options to the Buyer: Including possible Seller-paid rate buydown options, Seller paid Buyer closing costs or possible other options on the Buyer's behalf. Contact us for a tour today!

400 E Locust Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Debra Johnson of Coldwell Banker Pasternak Johnson.

1401 N Penn Avenue, Independence
$99,000
Turnkey Car Wash Investment Opportunity! Take advantage of a rare opportunity to own a well-maintained, income-producing car wash with significant recent upgrades and a feature that sets it apart from the competition—the only 14-foot high bay in the area designed to accommodate commercial trucks, RVs, trailers, and boats. This self-service facility has seen extensive improvements, including new high-pressure water lines and chemical lines servicing all four bays, new handles, nozzles, and spray tips, plus upgraded equipment throughout the property. Customers will appreciate the convenience of self-serve payment options with new coin/bill meters and credit card readers powered by the CryptoPay system. Recent updates include 2 vacuums, new air machine, new air compressor, new coin changer hopper, new motor for the spot-free rinse system, two tankless hot water heaters, and all new protective PC piping for water and chemical lines. Whether you're an investor looking to expand your portfolio or an entrepreneur seeking a business with modernized equipment and growth potential, this car wash offers a strong foundation with major capital improvements already completed. The combination of truck and boat accessibility, updated technology, and customer-friendly amenities makes this a standout business opportunity.

1401 N Penn Avenue, Independence

Listing courtesy of Amber Gregory of Keller Williams Realty Select.

612 Catalpa Street, Independence
$314,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
New Construction! Seller is offering $10,000 in concessions to the buyer. Ask me for details! Jefferson Subdivision is an all new area of Independence with multiple builders to suit everyone's style! Take a look at this home which has the BEST backyard out of all of the homes! Vaulted ceilings, blank slate on walls so you can paint it, wallpaper it, stone it, whatever you may choose to accent to your style! Some pictures are of similar property 506 Catalpa. Will update pictures once construction is complete. It has an open concept which includes kitchen, living area and dining area. Large eat in bar area with quartz countertops, pantry space, light tan cabinetry and black long handles knobs. Main bedroom has a large walkin closet, double vanities, double walkin shower with bench and private toilet room. It is located on the east end of the home and the other 2 bedrooms with additional office space or another bedroom are located on the west end along with a full bath. Ample storage throughout the home. This is style #3 out of 4 styles that were built specifically by the owner. Call today for your private showing and let's get you settled in by summer or back to school.There is a 1 year builder warranty included.

612 Catalpa Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Amber Gregory of Keller Williams Realty Select.

621 Catalpa Street, Independence
$344,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
NEW CONSTRUCTION | Jefferson Subdivision This one's brand new and ready for its first family. Tucked into the Jefferson subdivision, this ranch-style home gives you 1,813 square feet of easy, open living—the kind of layout that just makes sense once you're actually living in it. Walk in and you'll notice it right away: lots of natural light, an open feel, nothing closed off. The family room, kitchen, and dining space all flow into one another, so whether it's a weeknight dinner or a house full of people for the game, nobody's stuck in another room by themselves. The kitchen is built for real life—big island, plenty of counter space, room to actually cook and hang out at the same time. There are 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a bonus office that can be whatever you need it to be—work-from-home space, playroom, workout room, or just a place to shut the door for a minute. The primary suite feels like an actual retreat—a generously-sized room, a bathroom that feels nice to be in, and a walk-in closet you won't outgrow anytime soon. Out back, the covered patio is made for evenings—coffee in the morning, drinks after work, watching the sunset without needing to do anything else. And the garage is oversized, so you've actually got room for the cars plus bikes, tools, or whatever hobby needs a home too. This home offers a one-year builder warranty AND up to $10,000 in seller paid concessions! This deal just got a whole lot better!

621 Catalpa Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Lori Wesselowski of Coldwell Banker Pasternak Johnson.

617 Catalpa Street, Independence
$309,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to 617 Catalpa in Independence’s desirable Jefferson Subdivision! This brand-new construction home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and 1,568 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. Located near the end of a quiet cul-de-sac and directly across from Jefferson Elementary, this property combines everyday convenience with the peace of a tucked-away neighborhood setting. Inside, this highly desirable floor plan features a spacious open-concept design that brings the living room, dining area, and kitchen together into one seamless gathering space—ideal for entertaining or simply keeping everyone connected during day-to-day life. The kitchen offers modern finishes, quality cabinetry, ample counter space, and includes a dishwasher, all while overlooking the main living area for both function and style. The split-bedroom layout provides excellent privacy, with the primary suite situated separately from the additional bedrooms. The primary bedroom serves as a comfortable retreat with its own private bath and generous closet space, while bedrooms two and three are positioned on the opposite side of the home with a shared full bathroom nearby—perfect for children, guests, or office use. A conveniently placed laundry area and attached garage add to the home’s practical appeal. Outside, you’ll enjoy backyard space, easy access to parks and schools, and a short golf cart ride to the Independence Country Club and golf course. Expected completion is the end of May, and the home includes a one-year builder warranty, making this a fantastic opportunity to own low-maintenance new construction in one of Independence’s newest developments.

617 Catalpa Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Kristina Fulk of L2 Realty, Inc..

3620 CR 3920 Road, Independence
$735,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4.5 Baths
You can stop scrolling—this is the one that ends the search. Set on 7.06 acres of quiet, private ground, this custom-built brick home delivers over 5,300 sq ft of space, presence, and quality you feel the second you walk in. With 5 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, and a full finished walk-out basement, it’s built to live in—but designed to impress. The moment you step through the front door, your eyes are pulled straight to the back wall of windows. Nothing but trees, wide-open nature, and a peaceful glimpse of Montgomery County State Lake. It’s the kind of view people hope for—and almost never find. This home wasn’t thrown together—you’ll notice that immediately. From the craftsmanship to the materials, every detail was intentional. An intercom system, built-in ceiling speakers, dimmable lighting throughout, and a layout that flows effortlessly between comfort and style. The main level offers everyday living that feels anything but ordinary, while the walk-out basement—with a full second kitchen—opens the door for entertaining, hosting, or multi-generational living. Step outside and it only gets better. Exotic tigerwood decking leads you down to a covered patio, creating the perfect space to take in the view and unwind. The backyard is fenced for pets, and the property is equipped with a whole-house Generac generator with its own propane tank, giving you peace of mind year-round. With two HVAC systems, a safe room, and a Clearstream aerobic septic system, this home checks boxes most don’t even think to ask about. This isn’t just a home—it’s the one people wait for.

3620 CR 3920 Road, Independence

Listing courtesy of Jackie Schierlman of EXP Realty LLC.

419 S 4th Street, Independence
$99,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
HUGE PRICE REDUCTION! Step into timeless charm with this character-filled bungalow that’s just waiting to be brought back to life! Featuring classic stucco and brick veneer, this home makes a statement from the start with its inviting covered front porch—perfect for morning coffee or winding down in the evenings. Inside, you’ll find beautiful original hardwood floors and the kind of craftsmanship and character you simply can’t recreate. The layout offers incredible space and flexibility with 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms on the main level, plus 3 additional bedrooms and a bathroom upstairs—ideal for a growing household or anyone needing extra room. The large kitchen provides plenty of space to reimagine and make your own, while the abundance of windows fills the home with natural light throughout. Situated on a large corner lot, there’s room to spread out both inside and out. The full unfinished basement offers excellent storage (or future potential), and while the old garage entrance is no longer functional, there is still convenient parking available. This is the kind of home that, with a little vision and some updates, could truly shine again and be restored to its original beauty. If you love character, space, and the opportunity to create something special—this one is calling your name!

419 S 4th Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Amber Gregory of Keller Williams Realty Select.

215 S 5th Street, Independence
$369,900
5 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths
A Greek revival mansion built exclusively for Harry Ford Sinclair, founder of the Sinclair Oil Company. This residence with 12 rooms was built in 1906, at a cost of $25,000. It is defined by its huge front porch pillars plus its distinctive red tile roof and gold masonry. It has seven bedrooms of which two reside in the attic as guest bedrooms. The fifth bedroom on the second floor can serve as a nursery. The home features an impressive entryway with a grand staircase leading to the second floor. The staircase also has shorter than usual risers to accommodate Mr. Sinclair’s limp from a hunting accident. Pay special attention to the first floor and its beautiful Birdseye Maple Woodwork with hand-carved features on the pillars and staircase. Other rooms on the first floor include a large living room, a dining room, a library/study and a kitchen with an attached laundry room. Two gorgeous fireplaces are located on the first floor (one in the living room and one in the Library/Study that also features pocket doors and a beamed ceiling). The Library/Study also has a half-bath and walks out to the large porch on the West side of the house. The second floor consists of four to five bedrooms with the Master bedroom at the front of the house that includes a full private bathroom. This bedroom also opens to a large balcony that extends the full length of the front porch and side porch on the South side. Another full bathroom is located on the second floor to serve the other bedrooms. The walkup attic is unfinished in the main part and has a nonfunctional bath that could be brought back to life. There is also a rainwater catcher that could be functional again. The basement houses a very cool poker/recreation room with beamed ceilings, tiled floor, fireplace and half bath as well. Beautiful landscaping with trees and flowers and its location on a quiet street near churches, the public library and downtown businesses make it the ideal place to call home!

215 S 5th Street, Independence

Listing courtesy of Cynthia White of Bill White Realty.

0000 5000 Road, Independence
$155,000
Nestled in a peaceful rural setting on a paved road lies this expansive 31-acre mol property offers the perfect blend of natural beauty and functional infrastructure. Fully fenced-in for security and livestock, the land features a mix of open fields and lightly wooded areas, making it ideal for farming, recreation, or building your dream home. At the heart of the property lies a huge pond, providing a scenic focal point as well as opportunities for fishing, wildlife watching, or simply relaxing by the water. The land also includes a large barn, perfect for equipment storage, animals, or conversion to a workshop. Adjacent to the barn is a lean-to building, ideal for additional covered storage or shelter. Whether you're looking for a homestead, a private retreat, or a hobby farm, this versatile piece of land is ready to accommodate your vision. Call for your showing today!

0000 5000 Road, Independence

Listing courtesy of Natalie Lakey of Golden Oak Real Estate, LLC.

00000C Liberty Lane, Independence
$250,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to the future of real estate. With three unique floor plans, this 3D printed home has three-bedrooms and two-bathrooms. Very modern and sleek ready to adapt to your unique preferences. Lower utility and maintenance costs make it an ideal choice for the long term. Balancing personal taste with practical considerations, such as durability, maintenance requirements, and overall budget. Key decisions range from flooring (LVP, tile, carpet) and paint colors, to fixtures (lighting, plumbing) and cabinet hardware, each contributing to the home's cohesive style, whether it be modern, traditional, or eclectic. Prioritizing quality materials in high-traffic areas and ensuring a harmonious flow between different rooms will help create a space that is both beautiful and resilient. Photos are design renderings. There are 10 lots available (behind Wal-Mart). Would also build on other landsites.

00000C Liberty Lane, Independence

Listing courtesy of Cynthia White of Bill White Realty.

00000B American Way, Independence
$200,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to the future of real estate! Welcome to the future of real estate. With three unique floor plans, this 3D printed home has twi-bedrooms and two-bathrooms. Very modern and sleek ready to adapt to your unique preferences. Lower utility and maintenance costs make it an ideal choice for the long term. Balancing personal taste with practical considerations, such as durability, maintenance requirements, and overall budget. Key decisions range from flooring (LVP, tile, carpet) and paint colors, to fixtures (lighting, plumbing) and cabinet hardware, each contributing to the home's cohesive style, whether it be modern, traditional, or eclectic. Prioritizing quality materials in high-traffic areas and ensuring a harmonious flow between different rooms will help create a space that is both beautiful and resilient. Photos are design renderings. There are 10 lots to choose from in Independence (behind Wal-Mart). Would also build on other landsites.

00000B American Way, Independence

Listing courtesy of Cynthia White of Bill White Realty.

00000A American Way, Independence
$165,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to the future of real estate! Welcome to the future of real estate. With three unique floor plans, this 3D printed home has two-bedrooms and one-bathroom. Very modern and sleek ready to adapt to your unique preferences. Lower utility and maintenance costs make it an ideal choice for the long term. Balancing personal taste with practical considerations, such as durability, maintenance requirements, and overall budget. Key decisions range from flooring (LVP, tile, carpet) and paint colors, to fixtures (lighting, plumbing) and cabinet hardware, each contributing to the home's cohesive style, whether it be modern, traditional, or eclectic. Prioritizing quality materials in high-traffic areas and ensuring a harmonious flow between different rooms will help create a space that is both beautiful and resilient. Photos are design renderings. Photos are design renderings. Ten Independence lots in Country Village are available (behind Wal-Mart). Would also build on other landsites.

00000A American Way, Independence

Listing courtesy of Cynthia White of Bill White Realty.

101 N Pennsylvania Avenue, Independence
$335,000
Prime Downtown Investment Opportunity - Corner Lot Building with Stable Tenants! Location: Heart of Downtown 101-110 N Penn Property Type: Mixed-Use Building Lot Type: Corner Lot Investment Highlights: 5 Fully Rented Apartments (Located on the second level) 7 Retail Spaces on the Main Level, with 5 Leased and 2 available for future tenants New Roof, New Sewer Lines, and New Zone Heating & Air – Each retail space has its own thermostat for optimal climate control Landlord Pays Water & Gas (Tenants cover electricity) All tenants wish to stay, ensuring a stable income stream Why Invest Here? Prime Downtown Location: A sought-after corner lot in the heart of the city's vibrant downtown. Attractive Cash Flow: 5 apartments with long-term tenants and 7 retail spaces, 5 of which are already filled. Recent Upgrades: The building has received a major investment in infrastructure with a new roof, updated sewer lines, and independent heating/air systems for each retail space. Solid, Steady Income: With the existing tenants eager to stay, you can step into a fully operational building and start earning immediately! The Perfect Opportunity to Invest in Independence! This building is a perfect blend of residential and retail spaces, offering a well-rounded, low-maintenance income stream in a growing, prime location. Whether you're a seasoned investor or just starting, this is the building you've been waiting for! ?? Call Today for More Details and Schedule a Viewing!

101 N Pennsylvania Avenue, Independence

Listing courtesy of Amber Gregory of Keller Williams Realty Select.

201 N Pennsylvania Avenue, Independence
$399,500
6.5 Baths
Building was erected in 1920 as the Commercial National Bank with over 36,000 square feet and total of 52,000 sq ft of area by including the basement. The building is concrete throughout including the the roof and floors and was built by the Brewster family. Modified roofs installed installed approx. 4 to 5 years ago by Bateson Roofing. 30 yr roofs. Kawneer windows were installed in 1997 at an approx. cost of $500,000. 2 elevators, one being original and updated work to elevator to be completed September, 2021. The basement is very functional for work space and has 2 bathrooms. The building has ADA entrance and 1 ADA bathroom located on the first floor. 2 walk in safes with one that is completely operational.The former board room for the bank is phenomenal as well as some of the ornate ceilings. Mr. Scott has taken very good care of this landmark building. The whole building is heated with steam heat and the boiler is inspected every year by the State as they issue a boiler certificate. Boiler was replaced in 1994. The building is 50% occupied and there are large offices available including the former pharmacy and restaurant area. Too much info to list. Financials available to qualified Buyers.

201 N Pennsylvania Avenue, Independence

Listing courtesy of Robert Pasternak of Coldwell Banker Pasternak Johnson.

The data relating to real estate displayed on this website comes in part from the Heartland Multiple Listing Service database compilation. The properties displayed on this website may not be all of the properties in the Heartland MLS database compilation, or all of the properties listed with other brokers participating in the Heartland MLS IDX program. Detailed information about the properties displayed on this website includes the name of the listing company.

The information displayed on this page is confidential, proprietary, and copyrighted information of Heartland Multiple Listing Service, Inc. (“Heartland MLS”). Copyright 2026, Heartland Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Heartland MLS and the company represented by this website do not make any warranty or representation concerning the timeliness or accuracy of the information displayed herein. In consideration for the receipt of the information on this page, the recipient agrees to use the information solely for the private noncommercial purpose of identifying a property in which the recipient has a good faith interest in acquiring. Data last updated . Terms of Use

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!